‘Nature Of The Crime’: HBO’s Powerful Look Inside The Parole System

168
carlos-rebollo-nature-of-the-crime
Carlos Rebollo (Courtesy of HBO)

Mark your calendars, Frens! HBO is dropping its latest must-watch documentary, “Nature of the Crime”, on Tuesday, December 10, at 10:00 p.m. ET/PT.

Nature-Of-The-Crime-Key-Art-HBO

Directed by Ricki Stern (“Here to Climb”) and Jesse Sweet (“The Murders Before the Marathon”), this gripping doc takes us deep into the U.S. criminal justice system to examine one of its most complex and controversial aspects—parole.

It’ll also be available to stream on Max, so no excuses!

The Parole Process Unmasked

Every year, thousands of people serve time in prison with the hope of earning parole—a chance to rejoin society.

But what does it take to get that second chance? 

“Nature of the Crime” digs into the lives of three incarcerated men navigating this life-altering process.

  • Todd Scott and Chad Campbell were convicted of murder as teenagers in New York and have spent over 30 years behind bars. Both have faced multiple parole denials despite being eligible for over a decade.
  • Carlos Rebollo, incarcerated in Connecticut for a crime committed at age 15, gets a chance under the state’s newly reformed parole laws.

The film examines their rehabilitation journeys, the emotional toll on their families, and the often unseen workings of parole boards.

‘Nature Of The Crime’

Filmed over four years, “Nature of the Crime” provides unparalleled access to parole hearings, court transcripts, and behind-the-scenes preparation.

From legal arguments by attorneys like Rhiya Trivedi and Rochelle Swartz to insights from former parole board members, the documentary reveals how decisions are influenced by remorse, politics, and even recent scientific studies on brain development in young offenders.

In New York, where parole denial is the norm for most of the 11,000 yearly cases, Todd and Chad brace for their sixth and tenth hearings.

Meanwhile, Connecticut’s groundbreaking Public Act 15-84, which factors in youth at the time of a crime, gives Carlos new hope for release after 24 years.

A Moral Dilemma

At its heart, “Nature of the Crime” raises tough questions:

  • How do we balance justice for victims with the possibility of redemption for offenders?
  • Should past crimes define a person forever, or can true rehabilitation warrant a second chance?

Who’s Involved

The documentary features a mix of perspectives, including family members, attorneys, and former parole board officials like James Ferguson and Carol Shapiro, as well as advocates like Pat Hendry, President of the New York Police Benevolent Association.

‘Nature Of The Crime’ Trailer

Don’t Miss This Eye-Opening Doc

Whether you’re a true crime junkie or just curious about the inner workings of the justice system, “Nature of the Crime”promises to be an emotional, thought-provoking journey.

Remember, the film premieres December 10 on HBO and Max.

Get ready to dive into one of the most important conversations about justice, rehabilitation, and the human spirit.


Lock In With Ice Cream Convos

  • Subscribe To Ice Cream Conversations on YouTube and TikTok!
  • Join Our Email List for more scoop, giveaways, and special events.
  • Share this post on socials!

Discover more from Ice Cream Conversations

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.